Reservations are accepted for parties of 10 willing to put up a $10-per-person deposit. Go early or late and be prepared to cool your heels (and wet your whistle) at one of the two bars.
When to Go
Sunday mornings take a leisurly start with brunch from 8am to 2pm.
The Extras
Lobster season starts in August and Blue Heaven's inclusion of this crustacean friend will make you wish it were August all year.
In Short More than 100 years ago, this colorful, ramshackle building and rambling courtyard were home to gambling, prostitution, cockfighting and boxing matches refereed by Ernest Hemingway. Now, home to more prosaic pursuits of dining, drinking and selling trinkets, it's an endearingly funky mishmash of picnic tables, bars, a gift shop, a water tower, a pingpong table, a rooster cemetery and actual roosters. It's everything eggs in the morning and Caribbean/continental for lunch and dinner.